Resources

AED White Papers & Research

What independent research and expert panels have found about AED readiness, maintenance, accessibility, public policy and survival, summarized in plain language with links to every original source.

At a Glance

What the Research Shows

Across countries and study designs, the same pattern appears: AEDs that look ready often are not, and expired pads, weak batteries and restricted access are the usual reasons.

15.4%of public AEDs inspected in Seoul were not ready to useKim et al., Scientific Reports, 2022
21%of U.S. public AEDs tested failed at least one phase of testingSutton et al., AHA Scientific Sessions, 2017
83.7%of not-ready AEDs had invalid (expired) electrode padsKim et al., Scientific Reports, 2022
~4%of U.S. out-of-hospital cardiac arrests involve an AEDCabañas et al., JAHA, 2025

Research Library

White Papers & Studies

Peer-Reviewed StudyReadiness & Maintenance2022

Trends in Maintenance Status and Usability of Public Automated External Defibrillators During a 5-Year On-Site Inspection

Kim TY, Jung Y, et al. · Scientific Reports · Sci Rep. 2022;12:10738

Inspectors checked public AEDs in Seoul, South Korea against a standard checklist every year from 2013 to 2017, a total of 23,619 inspections.

Key Findings

  • 15.4% of the AEDs inspected were not ready to use.
  • Invalid (expired) electrode pads were the leading cause, involved in 83.7% of not-ready AEDs, ahead of device malfunction (22.1%) and poor battery status (17.2%).
  • The share of AEDs with valid pads fell from 90.0% to 87.2% over five years, even as access, signage and device operation improved.
  • 44.1% of AEDs were not usable around the clock, most often because the building was not accessible 24 hours a day.
Research PresentationReadiness & Maintenance2017

Readiness of Public Access Defibrillators

Sutton B, Heimroth J, Crawford S, Sutton E, Matzke J · American Heart Association Scientific Sessions; reported by UofL News (April 21, 2017) · University of Louisville News, April 21, 2017

Researchers tested 322 public, non-hospital AEDs at 190 sites in four U.S. regions (Seattle, Suffolk County NY, Central Illinois and Louisville), following each manufacturer’s testing guidelines.

Key Findings

  • 21% of the AEDs failed at least one phase of testing.
  • 5% had expired batteries and would not power on.
  • In regions where more than 80% of AEDs were registered, battery failures were rare (none in Seattle, 2% in Suffolk County).
  • In regions with under 25% registration, test failure rates reached 19.8% (Louisville) and 38.2% (Central Illinois).
Expert ConsensusPolicy & Standards2025

American Heart Association Automated External Defibrillator Symposium: Summary and Recommendations

Cabañas JG, et al. · Journal of the American Heart Association · J Am Heart Assoc. 2025;14(7):e039291

A summary of the November 2023 AHA AED Symposium, where scientists, clinicians, industry and regulators reviewed why AEDs remain underused and what should change.

Key Findings

  • AEDs are used in only about 4% of out-of-hospital cardiac arrests in the United States.
  • The panel found no clear, universal standards for AED maintenance and upkeep, and called for standardized, simple maintenance and readiness plans.
  • It suggested modeling AED readiness on fire-extinguisher programs with regular inspection and testing, and Wi-Fi notifications for expiring batteries and pads.
  • Recommendations also include 24/7-accessible placement, local AED registration and universal AED signage.
Scientific ReviewAccess & Placement2024

The Impact of Locked Cabinets for Automated External Defibrillators (AEDs) on Cardiac Arrest and AED Outcomes: A Scoping Review

Oonyu L, Perkins GD, Smith CM, Vaillancourt C, Olasveengen TM, Bray JE; ILCOR BLS Task Force · Resuscitation Plus · Resusc Plus. 2024;20:100791

An international review of 10 studies examining whether locking AED cabinets prevents theft and vandalism, and how locks affect access in an emergency.

Key Findings

  • Theft, vandalism and missing-AED rates were generally below 2%, including at sites accessible 24/7.
  • Simulation studies found that locked or staff-controlled cabinets slowed AED retrieval.
  • None of the included studies measured patient outcomes.
  • The 2022 ILCOR guidance referenced in the review advises against locking AED cabinets.
White PaperPolicy & Standards2016

Legislative Strategies for Modernizing U.S. AED Laws

Lazar RA · Readiness Systems, LLC · Readiness Systems white paper, March 2016

A review of how state AED Good Samaritan laws were written as of March 2016, and of the gaps that may discourage organizations from deploying AEDs.

Key Findings

  • By the author’s criteria, only 5 states (10%) offered meaningful Good Samaritan immunity for AED programs at the time.
  • 34 states (67%) appeared to limit immunity to activities during AED use, leaving program decisions such as placement and training unprotected.
  • 19 states (37%) appeared to make immunity conditional on meeting operational requirements such as maintenance, training or agency notification.
  • The author concludes that well-run AED programs matter more than the laws themselves.
Peer-Reviewed StudyClinical Evidence2025

Escalating vs Fixed Energy Defibrillation in Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest Ventricular Fibrillation

Tang H, Wu R, Yin L, et al. · JAMA Network Open · JAMA Netw Open. 2025;8(4):e257411

A cohort study of 342 patients in 48 cities across China (2017–2023), comparing AEDs programmed with escalating higher-energy shocks against AEDs using a fixed lower energy.

Key Findings

  • The first shock briefly stopped ventricular fibrillation in about 93–94% of cases in both groups.
  • Only about half stayed terminated until the next rhythm analysis (49% vs 47%).
  • Escalating higher-energy regimens more often restored a sustained organized rhythm (34% vs 25%).
  • The difference was greatest in refractory cases after the third shock (35% vs 18%).
Scientific ReviewClinical Evidence2001

Improving Survival From Sudden Cardiac Arrest: The Role of the Automated External Defibrillator

Marenco JP, Wang PJ, Link MS, Homoud MK, Estes NAM 3rd · JAMA · JAMA. 2001;285(9):1193–1200

A foundational review of 101 peer-reviewed articles on AED technology, time to defibrillation and survival from sudden cardiac arrest.

Key Findings

  • Advances in AED design simplified operation, improved accuracy and reduced cost.
  • AED use by first responders and laypeople shortened time to defibrillation and improved survival in several communities.
  • Use by both traditional and nontraditional responders appeared safe and effective.
  • Early cost-effectiveness studies of AED use were favorable.

Summaries are prepared by AED Service America for general educational purposes and reflect each source as published. AED Service America is not affiliated with these authors or publishers. Please refer to the original publications for complete methods, findings and limitations.

Turn Research Into Readiness

The research is consistent: AEDs fail quietly when no one is tracking pads, batteries and access. AED Service America provides nationwide onsite AED maintenance and management to keep every device Response-Ready.