White Paper One · Clinical Evidence

Fixed vs. Escalating Energy Defibrillation: What New Research Means for AED Owners

A plain-language review of a 2025 JAMA Network Open study comparing fixed and escalating shock energy in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest.

Study TypeRetrospective cohort study
PublishedJAMA Network Open, 2025
Patients342 adults with OHCA and VF
Regimens Compared200-300-360 J vs 200-200-200 J

Executive Summary

When an AED delivers a shock, it follows an energy sequence programmed into the device. Some AEDs deliver the same energy for every shock (a fixed regimen). Others increase the energy with each shock that follows (an escalating regimen).

A 2025 cohort study published in JAMA Network Open compared these two approaches in adults who experienced out-of-hospital cardiac arrest with ventricular fibrillation (VF). Both regimens stopped VF at the first shock in most cases. But the escalating higher-energy regimen was more likely to keep VF from returning and to restore an organized heart rhythm, particularly in patients who needed several shocks.

The first shock worked about equally well in both groups. The difference appeared afterward, in whether the heart stayed out of ventricular fibrillation.

Why Shock Energy Matters

Ventricular fibrillation is a chaotic heart rhythm that stops the heart from pumping blood. The study notes that VF is the initial rhythm in up to 40% of out-of-hospital cardiac arrests, and that survival is far more likely when VF is treated with rapid, effective defibrillation than when the heart is in asystole or pulseless electrical activity.

Defibrillation is not always a single event. In many cardiac arrests, VF stops after a shock and then returns. Some patients remain in VF after several shocks, a condition called refractory VF.

According to the study authors, the 2020 American Heart Association guidelines and the 2021 European Resuscitation Council guidelines support increasing shock energy when a shock fails or VF recurs, but more clinical evidence on the benefit of higher energy has been needed.

The Study at a Glance

342Adults with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and VF who received at least one shock
782VF defibrillations analyzed from rhythm data recorded automatically by the AEDs
48 citiesAcross China, with data collected from 2017 to 2023

All AEDs in the study came from the same model series and had their energy sequence programmed before the study began. Each AED delivered one of two regimens:

Escalating Higher-Energy Regimen

200 J → 300 J → 360 J

Used for 218 patients (480 VF episodes).

Fixed Lower-Energy Regimen

200 J → 200 J → 200 J

Used for 124 patients (302 VF episodes).

The regimen each patient received depended only on which AED was available, and rescuers did not know which regimen the device used.

Key Findings

1. The first shock worked in both groups

At the first shock, both groups received 200 J. VF was briefly terminated in 94% of cases in the escalating group and 93% in the fixed group, with no significant difference.

2. VF often came back

Only about half of those VF episodes remained terminated until the next rhythm analysis (49% vs 47%). The authors observed that most patients with refractory VF were not resistant to shocks. Their hearts left VF after a shock but could not stay out of it.

3. Escalating energy more often restored an organized rhythm

Across all shocks, VF treated with the escalating regimen was more likely to convert to a sustained organized rhythm (34% vs 25%).

4. The gap widened in refractory VF

In patients who needed repeated shocks, the escalating regimen established an organized rhythm more often after the second shock and above (24% vs 13%) and after the third shock and above (35% vs 18%).

The authors concluded that when a first shock at conventional energy fails, defibrillation with more energy is a better choice, and that escalating regimens might be preferred for patients with shockable rhythms.

What the Study Did Not Show

The authors identified several limitations, and they matter when interpreting these results:

  • It was a retrospective observational study. It shows an association between energy regimens and rhythm outcomes, not cause and effect.
  • The main outcomes were heart rhythms after shocks. Survival to hospital discharge and neurological outcomes were not reported in this analysis.
  • Data on rescuers, medications and other basic life support factors were not available.
  • Myocardial injury from higher-energy shocks was not measured. The authors note that the European Resuscitation Council reports no evidence of harm in humans from biphasic energies of up to 360 J.
  • The number of patients was limited, and all AEDs came from a single model series used in one country.

The authors call for larger prospective studies. The findings add to earlier research, including a 2005 randomized trial cited in the paper, that also favored escalating higher energy in patients with refractory VF.

What This Means for AED Owners

AED owners do not choose shock energy during a rescue. The AED follows the sequence its manufacturer and configuration determine. That is exactly why this research is relevant to how an AED program is managed.

Know what your AEDs are designed to deliver

Different AED models deliver different energy sequences. Understanding the energy capability of each device in your deployment, as documented by its manufacturer, belongs in any informed AED program review, particularly when you are planning replacements or expanding to new locations.

Never change device settings on your own

Any change to an AED’s configuration should follow the manufacturer’s instructions and your program’s medical direction. Research findings like these are a reason to ask informed questions, not to alter equipment.

Keep manufacturer protocol updates current

Manufacturers sometimes release updates affecting shock sequences, CPR prompts or operating software. Confirming that applicable updates have been completed is part of keeping an AED aligned with current manufacturer guidance.

An AED can only deliver its programmed sequence if it is Response-Ready

Every shock in an escalating sequence requires the battery to charge the device’s high-voltage circuitry again, and every shock depends on electrode pads that make proper contact with the patient. Expired pads, aging batteries and unresolved recalls can undermine the device regardless of its energy design.

Shock energy research only matters if the AED on your wall is ready to deliver every shock in its sequence.

How AED Service America Helps

AED Service America’s nationwide onsite AED maintenance and program management help organizations keep every device aligned with manufacturer requirements:

  • Manufacturer-specific inspections of each AED, its indicators, accessories and documented service requirements.
  • Proactive pad and battery replacement based on manufacturer expiration and installation-date requirements.
  • Manufacturer’s audits that review recalls, field corrective actions, and manufacturer-supported changes to shock sequences, CPR prompts or operating software.
  • Centralized records of every device, its location and its component history.
  • Free in-service training for all clients.

Have a question about the AEDs in your deployment? Our team can help you review what you have and what the manufacturer requires.

Source and Citation

Tang H, Wu R, Yin L, Hao W, Shi J, Zhu H, Xu S, Xu J. Escalating vs Fixed Energy Defibrillation in Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest Ventricular Fibrillation. JAMA Network Open. 2025;8(4):e257411. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2025.7411

Read the full open-access study: PubMed Central (PMC12042058). The original article is published under a CC-BY license.

This white paper is an independent plain-language summary prepared by AED Service America for educational purposes. It is not medical advice, and it is not affiliated with or endorsed by the study authors or the journal. Consult your AED manufacturer and medical director regarding device configuration.

Is Every AED in Your Deployment Ready to Deliver Every Shock?

Let AED Service America review your AEDs against manufacturer requirements, from pads and batteries to recalls and protocol updates.