Case Study · Higher Education

14 AEDs. Six Years Under Recall. No One Knew.

How AED Service America’s manufacturer’s audit uncovered a critical safety concern at a Washington State university.

IndustryHigher Education
Finding14 AEDs under recall
Unidentified ForApproximately six years
Confirmed ByThe AED manufacturer

Client Background

A large university in Washington State engaged AED Service America to provide professional AED maintenance and management services.

Before assuming responsibility for the university’s AED program, AED Service America initiated its standard manufacturer’s audit, a process we call an AED Healthy Checkup.

We believe it would be irresponsible to assume responsibility for maintaining lifesaving medical equipment without first understanding its history, condition, manufacturer support status, and potential safety concerns.

The Challenge: Six Years Under Recall Without Knowing It

During our initial AED manufacturer’s audit, we discovered something alarming.

Fourteen AEDs at the university had been subject to a manufacturer’s recall for approximately six years.

The university was unaware of the issue.

AED Service America contacted the AED manufacturer directly to investigate. The manufacturer’s technical support representative confirmed that all 14 affected devices needed to be removed from service immediately.

Without this audit, the university might have continued deploying these AEDs without knowing they were subject to a critical manufacturer safety action.

The devices were physically present. But their continued suitability for emergency use had not been verified.

Why the Problem Mattered

AEDs are FDA-regulated medical devices designed to deliver lifesaving treatment during sudden cardiac arrest.

A normal AED status indicator does not necessarily establish that a device is free of manufacturer recalls, required corrective actions, or other safety concerns.

Failure to identify these issues can result in:

  • AEDs remaining in service despite unresolved manufacturer safety notices.
  • Required repairs, updates, or component replacements being overlooked.
  • Increased liability exposure for the organization.
  • Potential equipment malfunction during a cardiac emergency.
  • A false sense of security regarding AED readiness.

An AED can appear operational while still requiring critical manufacturer-directed action.

Understanding AED Recalls and Field Corrective Actions

Not every FDA medical device recall requires permanent removal of the affected device.

Depending on the manufacturer’s instructions, a recall may require:

  • Removal of the AED from service.
  • Replacement of affected pads or batteries.
  • A software update or equipment modification.
  • Inspection, repair, or another field corrective action.

A field correction may itself be part of an FDA recall. The appropriate response depends on the specific safety notice and manufacturer’s instructions.

In this university’s case, the manufacturer explicitly confirmed that all 14 affected AEDs required immediate removal from service.

Our Solution: The AED Healthy Checkup

AED Service America’s manufacturer’s audit goes beyond a routine visual inspection.

Before assuming management responsibility, we investigate each AED model’s manufacturer history and current support requirements.

Our Healthy Checkup evaluates seven critical areas:

Manufacturer Recalls

Are any AEDs or replacement components affected by an active or unresolved manufacturer recall?

Field Corrective Actions

Have all required repairs, modifications, and software updates been completed?

AED Age and Service Life

How old are the devices, and does the manufacturer continue to support their use?

Warranty and End-of-Life Status

Are the AEDs still under warranty? If not, can they safely remain in service under manufacturer guidance?

CPR and Operating Protocol Updates

Are there manufacturer-supported changes to shock sequences, CPR prompts, or operating software that need to be implemented?

Manufacturer Support and Indemnification

Are there limitations or changes affecting manufacturer support, liability provisions, or indemnification?

Continued Service Eligibility

Can the existing AEDs safely remain deployed, or is replacement necessary?

Our objective is simple: Keep every AED safely in service for as long as the manufacturer supports its continued use.

Complete Transparency: Answers Directly From the Manufacturer

AED Service America does not rely on assumptions about the condition or support status of an AED.

We contact manufacturers directly and obtain specific guidance concerning the equipment under review.

As part of our standard process, we provide clients with the relevant manufacturer correspondence so they can understand:

  • What questions were asked.
  • What the manufacturer confirmed.
  • Which corrective actions may be necessary.
  • Whether continued use is supported.
  • Whether any equipment must be removed from service.

This transparency allows clients to make informed decisions based on manufacturer guidance rather than unsupported recommendations.

Verified Results: 14 Recall-Affected AEDs Identified

Our manufacturer’s audit uncovered a significant safety concern that had remained unidentified by the university for approximately six years.

The findings:

  • 14 AEDs were identified as affected by a manufacturer recall.
  • Approximately six years had passed since the recall was initiated.
  • Direct manufacturer confirmation established that all 14 devices required immediate removal from service.
  • The university was informed of the findings and the manufacturer’s instructions.
  • A previously unrecognized safety concern was identified before AED Service America assumed ongoing program management.
  • The university received the information necessary to address the affected equipment and make informed decisions regarding replacement.

The Lesson Learned: An AED Inspection Is Not a Manufacturer’s Audit

A routine AED inspection may confirm that:

  • The device is physically present.
  • The readiness indicator appears normal.
  • Pads and batteries have not expired.
  • The cabinet and accessories are in acceptable condition.

However, these observations alone cannot establish whether the AED is subject to an unresolved recall, field correction, or manufacturer support restriction.

You cannot fully evaluate an AED’s readiness without understanding its manufacturer history.

That is why AED Service America performs a manufacturer’s Healthy Checkup before assuming responsibility for an AED maintenance and management program.

Protecting Lives While Preserving Capital

An older AED does not automatically need replacement simply because its original warranty has expired.

Likewise, a relatively new AED is not automatically free of manufacturer safety concerns.

Some AEDs can remain in service beyond their original warranty periods when the manufacturer continues to support their use.

Others may require removal because of recalls, end-of-service-life restrictions, or other manufacturer instructions.

AED Service America evaluates each situation individually. We do not automatically recommend replacing an entire AED deployment simply because the equipment has reached a particular age.

Our responsibility is to protect lives while helping clients preserve capital by avoiding unnecessary AED replacements.

The AED Service America Difference: A Culture of Caring

A manufacturer’s audit takes time.

It requires research, communication with manufacturers, review of technical information, and careful documentation.

We believe that work is essential.

AED Service America performs these Healthy Checkups as part of its commitment to responsible AED program management. We also offer manufacturer audit assistance to organizations that are evaluating the condition and safety of their existing AEDs.

Our philosophy is straightforward:

We would rather help an organization identify a potential safety concern today than discover after an emergency that an important manufacturer warning was overlooked.

This approach reflects our culture of caring, commitment to transparency, and belief that trust must be earned through actions.

Do You Know Your AEDs’ Manufacturer History?

Your AEDs may have current pads, functioning batteries, and normal status indicators.

But can you confidently answer these questions?

  1. Are any of your AEDs subject to an unresolved manufacturer recall?
  2. Have all required field corrective actions been completed?
  3. Are your AEDs still supported by their manufacturers?
  4. Are there required software or operating protocol updates?
  5. Can you document the manufacturer’s recommendations for continued use?

If you cannot confidently answer these questions, your AED program may benefit from a manufacturer’s Healthy Checkup.

Request an AED Healthy Checkup

Let our team help you understand what equipment you have, what requires attention, and which AEDs can safely remain in service.